How to Be a Good Writing Partner

This is bad. This is boring. Your character is unrealistic. I don’t read this genre.¹ 

Have you ever given harsh or unhelpful feedback? It’s easy to slip into the role of ruthless professor or critical editor instead of supportive writing partner.

Many writers have learned to give feedback in environments that emphasize criticism over collaboration. If you notice your remarks are too opinionated or overly blunt, you might have been trained to critique that way. But being a writing partner isn’t about telling someone how to write, what sounds good to you, or even what’s correct.

As a writing partner, your goals are to:

1. Encourage the writer to write. 
2. Help the writer find their authentic voice. 
3. Provide feedback aligned with the level of editing they request.

If your edits interfere with goals 1 or 2, it’s time to reconsider how you approach the critique.

How to Make Feedback Constructive

Clarify your immediate reaction for your writing partner without criticizing or correcting by using a question.

1. Think about what’s bothering you.
2. Pinpoint the issue in the text—it might not start where you noticed it. 
3. Form a clarifying question to guide the writer.

Five Examples

Think The character is far away when the fight starts, then he throws a punch.

Pinpoint I didn’t know that the character moved into the next room. 

Question When does the character arrive in the room? 

Think The character’s behavior didn’t match their internal thought. 

Pinpoint I attributed an internal thought to this character.

Question Which character has this inner thought? 

Think I was fully immersed in the story, then became aware of the writing. 

Pinpoint I became aware of reading when a character recapped the dialog. 

Question Why is the previous conversation explained here? 

Think I had to reread this sentence to understand it. 

Pinpoint After a long sentence, I forgot who was doing the action. 

Question Who is performing the action in this sentence? 

Think The horse turned out to be important, but I didn’t remember what it looked like.

Pinpoint The horse was described as glossy black. 

Question What distinguishes this horse from other black horses?

If you need to rewrite a sentence to understand why it feels off, that’s fine—but keep your rewrite to yourself. The goal isn’t to impose your voice on the writer’s work, but to help them refine their own.

Balance Your Critique

A helpful critique should consist of: 

• Two parts praise: Highlight what’s working well and why. 
• One part critique: Use questions to encourage reflection and guide revisions. 
• One part editing if requested: Edit for minor issues such as typos, filler words, filter words, paragraph breaks, unclear pronouns, and echoes (repeated words or phrases). 

––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––

¹ If you’ve offered to critique their work, you now read in their genre. If you feel under-qualified to comment on something unfamiliar, like world-building in fantasy, rhyming in poetry, or sexuality in an erotic novel, don’t comment on that aspect.